What we know and do not know. The NTSB has determined no cause for the Miami overrun, the Yosemite accident or the Chatsworth accident. The Miami preliminary report describes a fast, long landing in changing wind, a first-time crew pairing and a runway end with no arresting system. We draw no conclusion from that. The value for a risk owner is in the controls any contract owner would want around flying done for them.
Three accidents, three contracts. A cargo flight for a retailer, a firefighting contract and a television news arrangement look different, yet each had an operator flying for a named customer. In each the customer set tasks, schedules and sometimes performance terms. The contract owner usually sees the operator’s certificate and audit summary, not the day-to-day flying.
Experience and pairing are visible if you ask. The preliminary report records the captain’s hours on type and that the two pilots first flew together that day. Hours on type and crew pairing are simple to specify and to sample in a contract, and they sit alongside the operator’s own training and checking.
The edges of the airport belong to someone too. Five people on the ground died in a vehicle on a perimeter road near the runway end. Who controls vehicles near runway ends during landings, and what protects them, are airport questions a contract owner can still ask when they send heavy aircraft to a site.
Six controls to verify for contracted cargo, firefighting and helicopter work
Mapped to BARS (CAO v11) · SWA services
VERIFYDoes it work here, today?
PRIORITISEWhat matters most?
CONTROLWhat keeps it working?
ASSUREIs it still working?
Test landing performance and go-around discipline when the wind changes
When the wind moves toward a tailwind in the last minutes of an approach, who recalculates landing distance, what is the operator’s tailwind limit and what triggers a go-around? Ask for the procedure and for the last go-around reports from the airports you use.
BARSCAO v11 · Control 5.7 Stabilized Approaches; 5.8 Mandatory Go-around Procedures
SWAOperational reviews
Map the contracted flying you cannot see
List every flight flown for you by someone else, by task, aircraft type and site, then mark where you see only the certificate and the audit summary. Put assurance effort on the flying with the least visibility and the most severe outcome, such as heavy aircraft into airports with limited overrun protection.
BARSCAO v11 · Common Control 1.15 Operational Risk Assessment; 1.13 Aircraft Operator SMS
SWAAviation exposure baseline and risk profile
Write crew experience and pairing minimums into the contract
Set minimum hours on type for new captains and first officers and a rule on pairing two new crew members, then check them against the crew records. Specify them in the contract rather than relying on the operator’s own policy.
BARSCAO v11 · Common Control 1.4 Flight Crew Qualifications, Experience and Recency; 1.5 Flight Crew Check and Training
SWAOperator endorsement and contracting support
Check overrun protection and who controls the perimeter
For each airport your heavy aircraft use, confirm the runway-end safety area or arresting system, and who controls vehicles and people on perimeter roads during landings. Write the answer into the arrangement.
BARSCAO v11 · Control 2.3 Landing Site Assessments; 2.2 Airfield Inspections
SWAAerodrome, helipad and project aviation planning
See how crews actually fly your contract
Use flight data, tracking or sampling of approach stability and go-arounds on ordinary days, so you see the flying and not only the procedures. Act on the trends.
BARSCAO v11 · Common Control 1.13 Aircraft Operator SMS; Defence 19.5 Flight Following
SWACritical control verification
Confirm directive close-out on contractor aircraft
For production-defect directives such as the A320-family gear support inspection, ask how the operator identifies affected serial numbers, confirms inspection and checks work done by third-party maintenance.
BARSCAO v11 · Control 10.10 Critical Maintenance Tasks and Independent Inspections
SWASpecialist aviation advisory
Critical controls that matter this month
Four of the five critical controls bear on this topic. Fuel does not feature this month.
Weather
The Miami preliminary report records a wind change in the hour before landing and a clearance without wind. Ask how crews get the wind at the time of landing and whether landing performance is recalculated when thunderstorms shift it.
BARSCAO v11 · Control 2.6 Destination Weather Reporting; Control 3.2 Flight Plan Weather Data
Personnel
The report records about 150 hours on type for the captain and a first-time pairing that day. Ask whether your contract sets hours-on-type and pairing rules, and sample six flights against the crew records.
BARSCAO v11 · Common Control 1.4 Flight Crew Qualifications, Experience and Recency; Common Control 1.5 Flight Crew Check and Training
Infrastructure
Five people on a perimeter road died beyond the runway end. Ask whether the operator assessed overrun risk for its heaviest aircraft at each airport, and who controls vehicles near runway ends during landings.
BARSCAO v11 · Control 2.3 Landing Site Assessments; Control 2.2 Airfield Inspections
Aircraft
The Airbus directives trace to supplier production defects. Ask how the operator confirms affected serial numbers are inspected, including work by third-party maintenance.
BARSCAO v11 · Common Control 1.8 Basic Aircraft Equipment Fit; Control 10.10 Critical Maintenance Tasks and Independent Inspections
Close the loopInside your own organisation, make one person the owner of the operator’s performance and have them report go-arounds, tailwind landings, crew-pairing exceptions and airport overrun-risk findings to the executive and board who accepted the risk. Send the decisions back down to the logistics, procurement and site teams that set delivery schedules and choose airports, so a delivery deadline is never agreed without knowing the margin on the landing.